Missing Middle

MM_Pano.jpg

               

Speak out Against the "Missing Middle Vision"

Use our sample letter and email it to countyboard@arlingtonva.us

The Board will Vote in December or January on a "Request to Advertise" New Ordinances, with Final Vote 60 Days Later

On April 28, 2022, Arlington County staff released its Missing Middle Housing Study (MMHS) Phase Two report givng us a preview of plans to change half of the county's land area from single to multi-family zoning.  That draft, and an updated version of proposed zoning ordinances released October 31, would:

  • allow up to 8-plexes in all residential lots where they are not now allowed (with options to allow "only" 6-plexes, or to allow "only" fourplexes on all lots, with further tiering that would allow up to 8-plexes on lots over 9,000 square feet and larger);

  • reduce on-site parking requirements for most Missing Middle lots (with options to vary requirements based on distance to mass transit);

Even with new options designed to address community concerns on excess density and inadequate parking, the October 31 version of the plan represents SIGNIFICANT new infill and population growth, possibly up to 7 times the current allowance.  Staff has indicated it may still add options for the Board to consider imposing an annual cap on the number of Missing Middle units; we expect such a cap will be introduced at a November30 meeting of the Zoning Committee.  Even with a cap, it cannot impede a full buildout according to whatever final terms the Board approves.  Although County  Attorney Corr told the Board that Missing Middle zoning could be "rolled back" at a later date, ASF believes that the new code would be irreversible. The board will not finalize new code until possibly March 2023, but all options on the table now will:

  • accelerate population growth that was already projected to add 63,000 people from 2018 to 2040, for whom the county conducted no new infrastructure or other key planning;

  • understate major impacts of much higher populations and teardowns;

  • exacerbate the gentrification being caused by Missing Middle zoning ALREADY in effect in historically-Black neighborhoods;

  • cause hardships for those at lower income levels.

Some options, if chosen, could:

  • result in much smaller developable lots, with implications not yet fully assessed;
  • make it more difficult for those earning below the median income of $108,00 to find affordable housing in Arlington, OR require SIGNIFICANT NEW SUBSIDIES for those earng below 50% of median income; 

  • normalize parking a block from your house;

  • result in a 49% reduction of tree canopy on newly-developed lots 

The county says there is no need to plan for more infrastructure, including schools, stormwater, or truly affordable housing; even the Joint Facilities Advisory Commission is concerned that density is getting ahead of our infrastructure financing.

If you are worried about negative impacts of extreme infill,  use our sample letter and email it to countyboard@arlingtonva.us

 

ASF will continue to ask the county to:

  1. Fully reveal population growth that is allowed by maximum buildout of new zoning;

  2.  Study the fiscal, environmental and displacement impacts of the proposed 8-plex vs. current land use and zoning;

  3. Consider measures that are not irreversible nor as inflexible as zoning tools to address housing needs;

Further Actions:

  • Sign this petition sponsored by Arlingtonians Opposed to Upzoning!

  • Email ASF to volunteer to speak at the first Board Meeting that will allow unlimited public comment or to volunteer or request a yard sign! ASF.virginia@gmail.com

_______________________________________________

​​​Key Links:

ASF MM Links:

Arlington County MMHS Phase Two Links:

Civic Groups/Arlington Non-Profit/Arlington Resident Inputs on MMHS Phase Two

Other Resources on Upzoning in Arlington and Beyond

_____________________________________________________________________________

 

​​ASF also questions the "major housing crisis for mid-level earners" battle cry that has accompanied Arlington's MM campaign.  Zillow in January 2021 showed 335 homes/townhomes for sale in Arlington under $800,000 out of 536 total units, showing relatively robust supply.  The Missing Middle effort -- like an October 2020 failed effort to change affordable homeownership programs -- seems to favor higher income households at the expense of lower income groups

ASF is concerned that the county's MM plans, as with its other development plans -- including extensive new density along Langston Boulevard, is untethered from fiscal reality.  See the January 2021 ARLNow article by Peter Rousselot (ASF member) for more information on the tax implications of growth. Arlington in 2018 committed to the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments that it would add residents equal to the combined populations of Charlottesville and Culpeper, approximately 65,000.  But five years on, the County has not budgeted for any added facilities such as schools or parks for these new residents.  In February 2022, the County Board approved a new sector plan for Pentagon City that will add 12,000 new residents to the 8,000 now living in that area over the next 40 years -- almost equal to the entire population of Falls Church -- without budgeting funds or public space to add adequate infrastructure. The County says it also won't need to budget for infrastructure or public services as it looks at densifying the Langston Boulevard Corridor.  And, no surprise, the April 28 Missing Middle study and corresponding analysis projects no new schools or facilities are needed despite up-zoning all remaining single-family areas that do  allow new multifamily projects currently.  The claim is not credible.

 

Additional Resources:

Arlington County Documents/Resources

ASF Documents

Third-Party Documents

Towns%20of%2024_before_edited

BEFORE: Two homes, owned by African American Arlingtonians on a treed lot in the historic Green Valley neighborhood

Towns%20of%2024_after_edited

AFTER: Eight townhomes, each priced at $850K, in the new "Towns of 24th" development violate budgetary, environmental, and diversity principles

4341 n pershing (2)

Ballston Row townhouse list price $1.1 Million, July 2020 Photo: Gary Anthes

4341 n pershing (1)

Photo: Gary Anthes

Teardown_edited

Common Arlington cottage being torn down, along with with surrounding mature trees, to build a McMansion

house on 600sf lot

Single family home on tiny 1500 square foot lot sold in 2020 for $440,000. Zero yard. Missing Middle taken to the extreme?

Halls%20Hill%20duplex_edited

Newly built duplex in Halls Hill — a traditionally African American neighborhood — sold for $1.1 Million per unit

Freedmans%20Village%20gentrification_edi

Foxcroft Heights neighborhood — the last remaining area of the Freedman's Village — affordable homes give way to high-priced replacements

Lyon%20Park%20ADU1_edited

Lyon Park Auxiliary Dwelling Unit (ADU) adjacent to a single family home provides a source of rental income for homeowners.

Lyon%20Park%20ADU2_edited
Railroad%20Cottages_edited

Falls Church Railroad Cottages "affordable" units cost $700,000+

Railroad%20Cottages2_edited

Falls Church RR cottages - Missing Middle exemplar. City kept budget costs down by only allowing seniors (no school spending)

Gravel%20Bank%20plaque_edited

Falls Church Railroad Cottages MM were developed in 2016 on land owned and inhabited by African-American families and businesses since just after the Civil War